John Locke Writing Competition 2026 || Philosophy || Is it ever wrong to do the right thing for the wrong reasons?
John Locke Writing Competition 2026 || Philosophy || Is it ever wrong to do the right thing for the wrong reasons? I'm pleased to share an essay I submitted to the 2026 John Locke Essay Competition , which was shortlisted. Responding to the question “Is it ever wrong to do the right thing for the wrong reasons?” , I explore a question that sits at the heart of moral philosophy A group of student volunteers weekly at a severely understaffed soup kitchen. They arrive consistently, complete the work diligently, and, as a result, homeless individuals are fed and the kitchen remains operational. Yet their motivation is not compassion, but the desire to strengthen their university application. Is this wrong? At first glance, the answer can appear as no. Despite their motive, the direct outcome is unquestionably beneficial, where dependent individuals receive meals as the soup kitchen is further run efficiently. From a consequentialist perspective, the students...